Series · 10 parts
The Phygital Illusion
Phygital: the art of misunderstanding both sports and Esports — and monetizing the confusion
Versão em português: A Ilusão do Phygital.
Six rungs and no handrail
Start here. This series was written to be read in order: each part builds on the proof of the one before. Out of sequence, the arguments lose their meaning. Next part: The Great Phygital Illusion.
Nobody needs a license to invent a format, give it a name and sell it. Phygital may exist. It may have an audience, sponsors, prizes and thrilling matches. This series does not dispute its right to exist. It examines what is done with the name once it catches on: the ladder.
The six-rung ladder
The movement’s publicity climbs six rungs in a single breath, as if they were one:
- Format. Two contests, one digital and one physical, added into a single scoreboard. This is what exists, documented and broadcast.
- Discipline. The format is called a new sport, with its own identity, stable rules and athlete development.
- Movement. The new sport becomes an international movement, with a member network, ranking and calendar.
- Authority. The network presents itself as the body that represents the sport, country by country.
- Public endorsement. The self-declared authority appears with a legislative chamber, a secretary, a deputy and a government logo on the promotional piece.
- Public money. The endorsement becomes an argument for host cities, incentives, state sponsorship and transfers. This is the rung this series wants to lock before anyone climbs it: the target is tomorrow.
Each rung requires its own proof. Proof for rung three does not carry rung four; the photograph on rung five proves nothing on rung six. This series climbs the ladder rung by rung and marks, with date and source, the point where proof ends and the rhetoric keeps climbing. Six rungs, and no handrail.
Where I write from
I lead Esports organizations: CBDEL, PAMESCO and WESCO. I declare the interest before anyone discovers it and uses it as an argument. And I declare the other side of the coin: the demands I make here apply to my own organizations, and I accept them. Whoever demands transparency must be the first to deliver it.
What I wrote in 2025 and what I correct today
In September 2025 I published When the Physical Meets the Digital, a critique of Phygital. The critical position stands. Part of what I said does not. I put the old text to the documents, and two points did not survive:
- I wrote that Phygital was born in 2022 as a response to sanctions. The idea is older: the originator of an earlier project described, in October 2021, a version of the event for Russia, with a root he himself traces back to 2007 3. I correct that. But the institutional chronology is entirely after the start of the invasion of Ukraine: host chosen in June 2022, presidential decree in December 2022, recognition as a sport in January 2023 (Article III). The age of the idea is not the age of the scale, and the scale was decided with state money.
- I cited figures of US$ 10 million per national event and US$ 58 million for Kazan. For the first I found no source and I withdraw it. For the second, what is documented is larger: the Russian government announced roughly 5.3 billion rubles for 2023–2024 8, with a presidential decree ordering federal-budget funding 29, and The Moscow Times recorded, at the opening, a budget above 6 billion rubles, about US$ 65 million 9. I replace a figure I cited without a source with figures that have one.
What I keep. The expressions "front organizations" and "One Man Show" stay: they are my position, signed as opinion, and I name no entity. The criteria are the ones in my article Esports and the One Man Show Entities, of July 31, 2025. What this series adds is date and source for every fact.
Correcting yourself in public has an unpleasant side effect for the adversary: it removes his only easy defense, pointing at the critic’s error. Whoever corrects himself first earns the right to demand the rest.
How this series works
- Every fact has a source and a date of consultation, listed at the end.
- Every inference is labeled as inference.
- Every opinion is signed as opinion, without apology.
- Every question is a question. I do not accuse anyone of what I cannot prove. I ask what any citizen and any authority are entitled to know, and I ask with the document in hand.
Maximum force in opinion. Maximum discipline in proof. This combination is not caution. It is the most efficient form of attack I know, because it leaves the adversary not a single factual error to hold on to.
A preventive series
This series is conceptual and preventive. I do not accuse anyone of having received public money: I know of no document showing that for the Brazilian event. I write so that it does not happen without proof. Public money is the sixth rung of the ladder, and it is the one I want to protect. Whoever wants to climb that far will find, along the way, the questions already asked and the trail of every answer that did not come.
The thesis
Phygital works as an entertainment product. It works well, in fact. That is where what is proven ends. Everything that comes after (new sport, movement, authority, endorsement, public money) is a sequence of claims that requires demonstration and that, so far, has received publicity in its place. I call it by its name: the art of misunderstanding both sports, the physical and the electronic, and monetizing the confusion.
Opinion, signed. Phygital, as a claim to be a new sport, is an illusion and, in good part, a sporting folly. Folly not because it is fun, but because it promises what its own design does not deliver: a sport that depends, at every round, on a third party’s software, sold as a discipline with its own identity. Opinion cannot be proven and I do not hide it behind fact. What can be proven comes through the series, with source and date.
The Great Phygital Illusion
Part 2 of 10. This part assumes you have read Six rungs and no handrail. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
The word comes from marketing. Industry sources credit the popularization of the term, in 2007, to an advertising executive who used it to describe consumer journeys mixing physical stores and digital environments; Amazon Ads still uses it in that sense 1. The exact authorship of the word is disputable. Its nature is not: phygital was born to sell brand experience, not to organize sport.
This condemns no one by etymology. Words change address. What needs explaining is the change of nature: whoever takes a sales-funnel term and promotes it to "the future of sport" must say when, how and with what proof the thing stopped being a consumer experience and became a discipline. That explanation has not been given. It was replaced by more publicity.
The best of the defense, and why it is not enough
The smartest defense is the one about combinations: the triathlon joins three contests, the decathlon ten, and nobody says they lost value for not having invented running. I agree with the premise and disagree with the conclusion. Triathlon and decathlon have their own identity, a stable rulebook, balance among events, athlete development and decades of comparable results. Neither depends on software licensed by a third party that changes version, balance and terms of use whenever the publisher decides. Combining two things is a format. Stabilizing the combination is what makes it a discipline, and nobody has demonstrated that.
The hybrids that worked, and how they worked
There are real combinations, and it is worth seeing how they hold together. Modern pentathlon, created by Coubertin and on every Summer Games programme since 1912, lost its riding discipline through its own federation’s process: a consultation opened on November 4, 2021, two obstacle variants chosen from more than 60 proposals and tested, approval by 83% of the vote at the congress of November 12, 2022, and IOC endorsement on October 16, 2023 33. One may disagree with the result: the reigning Olympic champion threatened to leave the sport and a national federation appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport 33. But look at what the history shows. The one who decides to change a discipline is the sport, by vote, with testing, appeal and the IOC at the end. In Phygital, the digital stage changes when the game’s publisher updates the software.
The best counterexample to the claim that physical and digital demand a new movement is in cycling. In 2018 the UCI congress approved the integration of virtual cycling into the federation’s constitution; in 2019 the UCI partnered with a platform to create the rules; in December 2020 it held the first Cycling Esports World Championships, with athletes pedalling stationary bikes connected to the platform, real physical effort in a digital environment 32. The platform is replaceable: from 2024 the UCI handed the event to another one 32. The sport’s federation is in charge, not the software’s owner. That is the physical-digital integration model that exists and works, and it needed neither a movement nor a flag of its own.
The originator of the project that preceded the Games of the Future said himself, in October 2021, that his intention was not necessarily to invent sports but to adapt existing practices to the event 3. It is the best line of the defense and the best line of the prosecution: adapting existing practices to an event produces a format, not a discipline.
A festival under a single flag
In Astana, between July 29 and August 9, 2026, the Games of the Future brought together eight disciplines. Among them, hybrid football and basketball, but also Dota 2, Mobile Legends and PUBG, entirely digital competitions with no physical stage 4. The movement’s own development structure distinguishes hybrid, virtual and technological activities 2, and the event’s official FAQ separates, in the programme, "phygital sport" from "Esports" 35. In other words: Phygital’s main event is, in a relevant part, a multidisciplinary Esports festival with showcase hybrids. Nothing wrong with that. What is hard to swallow is using the flag of the whole to claim that everything in it obeys a single, unprecedented sporting principle.
The additionality test
If a city has a football championship and a simulator championship, it has two championships. If it adds the scores, it has a third product. What did sport gain? What talent is now developed in a way that was impossible before? What additional cost (two officiating teams, digital licensing, hybrid infrastructure, two production crews) was offset by what verifiable result? A private product does not need to answer that in order to exist. It needs to answer when it asks for endorsement, public policy or taxpayer money.
Promised, documented, still to be proven
| Promise | What is documented | What remains to be proven |
|---|---|---|
| Innovation | Combination of two contests on one scoreboard; good audiovisual production 4 | That the combination adds something the separate disciplines did not already offer |
| Inclusion | Use of the term in promotional material | Indicators of access, retention, participant profile and cost per athlete |
| Youth and physical activity | Appeal of the format as a spectacle | Any health outcome or continued sports practice among young people |
| Sustainability and legacy | Editions in different hosts: Kazan 2024, Abu Dhabi 2025, Astana 2026 49 | Financial statements, continuity without local public support, sporting legacy at the host |
| The complete athlete | Athletes who compete in both stages | That the combination produces a superior athlete or measures excellence in anything |
| Recognition | Own member network and ranking 511 | Recognition by established international federations or the Olympic Movement |
The illusion is not the event, which exists, nor the matches, which are contested. It is the ladder: from format to discipline, from discipline to movement. Each step requires its own proof. Where it is missing, publicity takes the place of demonstration.
Sport is not a marketing invention
Part 3 of 10. This part assumes you have read The Great Phygital Illusion. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
The entertainment industry needs intellectual property, narrative and a renewable product. Sports administration needs something else: competition criteria, predictable rules, representativeness, athlete protection, integrity and accountability of decision-makers. The two worlds coexist and finance each other. They are not the same world. The problem begins when the logic of creating a product is presented as if it were the logic of constituting a sport.
How a discipline enters the system
The movement’s own development structure describes the path: any interested party proposes a discipline; the proposal is assessed on competitiveness, entertainment and audience interest; the community validates it; at the end of the season, the most popular and attractive formats may enter the Games of the Future programme 2. It is a coherent process for event curation. It is simply not a process for constituting a discipline, because the market yardstick (popularity, attractiveness) is a declared part of the criteria. Between the requirements of a sport and those of a TV programme there is overlap, but not identity. That border is the point.
"Member" is not "federation"
The movement’s world community clarifies, in its own Q&A section, that candidates for membership need not be recognized sports federations: they may be companies, clubs, associations, educational institutions. It admits more than one member per country, provided they run different disciplines, and accepts that an existing entity may join without creating a specific federation 5. The same page gives the joining fee (US$ 100 for an associate member, US$ 500 for a full member, with new members entering as associates) and answers "no" to the question about requiring a federation 5. It is a legitimate model of a private network, and charging for membership is legitimate. But it is the opposite of a representative system: joining the network does not prove that one speaks for a sport, a country or an athlete. When someone displays "member" as if it were "national federation", that is label arithmetic.
Who rules, and with how many votes
The community’s charter, in its version revised on May 30, 2024, provides for member categories with distinct political rights, founders’ prerogatives and the possibility of additional votes tied to growth targets 6. Weighted voting is not exclusive to Phygital: it exists in well-known international federations 6. What matters is not the weighting itself but the whole: who decides the allocation, with what justification, with what counterweight, with what athlete voice and with what possibility of review. In a system where commercial growth can earn political power, the inevitable question is who protects sporting decisions from commercial incentives.
The community is not obliged to copy the Olympic Charter. But the IOC’s Basic Universal Principles of Good Governance, updated in 2022, are the natural yardstick for anyone presenting itself as part of international sports development: financial transparency, integrity, elections, controls, balance of powers 7. In August 2026, Phygital International’s chief executive stated that the movement has something to learn from the Olympic Movement precisely in governance, athlete-centered development and trust 24. I agree. Learning begins by admitting the gap. The admission is on record.
Two houses, one door
The structure is organized in two legal entities: a company that holds and commercially exploits the rights to the Games of the Future, and a non-profit membership organization that runs the qualifying stages 10. The split can be efficient; many sports combine associative bodies and commercial promoters. But the 2025–2026 ranking regulations were developed jointly by the two 11. In July 2026, the chair of the membership organization left to take over the company’s executive leadership; in September, his successor publicly called for a clearer separation between the structures, with reinforced governance and transparency 13. Rotation of executives is not an irregularity. But when the successor himself asks for more separation, the independence between the two houses stops being a closed matter and becomes a work in progress.
Owning the game is not owning the sport
Esports has been teaching this lesson for decades. The publisher controls the software and the brand; the promoter controls a tournament; the sporting organization seeks rules and athlete rights. When the roles are mixed, there is conflict. A game license does not give the publisher the right to represent athletes, and organizing a tournament does not make the promoter the owner of a sport. This applies to Phygital as it applies to anyone: whoever finances, licenses and broadcasts the spectacle does not thereby gain authority over the practice. Sporting authority is built with rules, remedies, representation and accountability. It is not bought with a sponsorship package.
The spectacle can be sold. The brand can be licensed. The community can be expanded. Sporting legitimacy does not come in the packaging of any of these products.
The geopolitics behind Phygital
Part 4 of 10. This part assumes you have read Sport is not a marketing invention. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
The easiest argument against a geopolitical reading is chronological: the idea predates the 2022 sanctions. That is true, and I incorporate it (Introduction). But the argument proves less than it seems. That the idea came earlier says nothing about who turned it into an international platform, with what money and for what purpose. Inventing a concept is one thing. Deciding that a state will fund it as a priority of external projection is another.
What the documents show
- In October 2021, the project’s originator described to a French outlet an event planned for Russia, with ambitions of large audiences and a conceptual root in 2007 3.
- A BUSINESS Online report of April 30, 2023 reconstructed the 2021 presentation of the project by the Russian deputy prime minister and reported, attributed to people linked to the project, an interest in creating a sports movement from which Russia could not be removed for having founded it 8.
- The Russian federal government announced funding of roughly 5.3 billion rubles for 2023–2024, in addition to Tatarstan resources 8. A presidential decree of December 19, 2022 ordered the tournament to be funded from federal budget appropriations and recommended that Tatarstan fund it too 29. The Moscow Times recorded, at the opening, a budget above 6 billion rubles, about US$ 65 million 9. These are announced and reported amounts, not an audit of execution.
- The Kazan edition, February 21 to March 3, 2024, opened with the Russian president and leaders of friendly countries. The Moscow Times reported, on March 4, 2024, expert assessments that the event sought to project normality amid isolation, and cautioned that its effectiveness was debatable 9.
- In February 2025, Kommersant reported supplier claims of roughly 587 million rubles against the unit responsible for the 2024 event 14. These are claims in court, some decided, others not. They are not a definitive debt of the movement.
The item about a movement "from which Russia could not be removed" is attribution to sources in a news report, not a confession by an official. I treat it as such. And, with that caveat, I repeat the question: if the project was born as a mere platform for sporting innovation, why did it need state budget priority, a presidential ceremony and the language of international projection?
Opinion. The inference that geopolitical ambition helped drive the Games of the Future is compatible with all the documents, though it proves neither exclusive motivation nor permanent Russian control. What cannot be done is to reduce Kazan to "an available venue".
The order of events
| Date | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Oct 2021 | The originator describes to a French outlet an event planned for Russia | 3 |
| Jun 16, 2022 | Kazan is announced as host at the St Petersburg Economic Forum, four months after the invasion of Ukraine began | 31 |
| Sep 21–23, 2022 | First Phygital Games, in Kazan | 31 |
| Dec 19, 2022 | Presidential decree No. 927: organizing committee and funding from federal budget appropriations | 29 |
| Jan 31, 2023 | Russia’s Ministry of Sport includes phygital sport in the national register of sports | 30 |
| Feb 22, 2023 | The Russian Phygital Sport Federation is created | 30 |
| Feb 21 to Mar 3, 2024 | Games of the Future in Kazan, opened with the Russian president, two years after the invasion began | 936 |
Read the middle column as one block. The idea is from 2021. Everything that made it an institution (host, decree, budget, registration as a sport, national federation) came after the war began. The most telling item is the recognition: in Russia it exists, it is a fact, and whoever denies it is wrong. But it came from the same state that, six weeks earlier, had decreed the tournament and assigned it a budget. Recognition by the one who pays is recognition of oneself. Outside Russia, I found no equivalent recognition by a traditional international federation or the Olympic movement. It may exist; I did not find it, and whoever has it should present it.
At the opening, the Russian president described the tournament as a space free of politics. The Moscow Times headlined, on March 4, 2024, that the inaugural edition failed to undo Moscow’s international isolation 9. Opinion: let the reader judge whether a space free of politics opens with a head of state and a state budget.
The next phase: from one state to the next
After Russia came Abu Dhabi (December 18–23, 2025) 28 and Astana (July 29 to August 9, 2026) 4. The event survived its debut, which weakens the easy prophecy that it would end. It does not, however, settle the underlying question: who owns the bill. According to The Times of Central Asia, the Kazakh government stated that funding would come exclusively from sponsorship 23. In September 2025, a Kazakh MP asked for the edition to be postponed, estimating its cost at 62 billion tenge, about US$ 115 million, equivalent in his words to at least six new schools, in a country whose national budget closed 2024 with a revenue shortfall of 570.8 billion tenge 23. The estimate is the MP’s, and the newspaper does not explain the calculation. But the 2025 edition had already been postponed to 2026 after floods led the government to redirect spending 23, and the 2026 event was announced with the name of a state fund in its title 24. The Times of Central Asia, in July 2026, describes that fund as the national fund, notes that the sponsor list is dominated by Kazakh banks and mining companies, and records that the country put its own money and institutions into the event 34. Money "exclusively from sponsorship" with a state sponsor is a category that calls for a footnote.
The organizers maintain that the company holding the rights is based in the United Arab Emirates, that the member community, incorporated in Hong Kong, is non-profit, and that no government runs the Games 10. I do not dismiss the statement. I note that it is a statement. The passage from state origin to international private operation is legitimate, provided it is demonstrated and not merely announced.
What the rest of the world did with sport, technology and the state
The International Olympic Committee, the unavoidable reference for anyone who speaks of a "movement", organized the Olympic Virtual Series (2021) and the Olympic Esports Week (2023) in collaboration with international federations and game publishers 16. On October 30, 2025, more than a year after announcing a 12-year deal, it ended its partnership with Saudi Arabia for the Olympic Esports Games, and announced a new approach after a period of reflection, without detailing its reasons 25. Two readings, both mine. First: the Olympic Movement, with more than a century of experience and its own governance structure, treats the relationship between Esports and state money as a matter for pause and review. Second: Phygital has already passed through three countries in three years, and nothing in the documents shows that accountability followed each change of flag. A Swiss newspaper summed up part of the European press’s reading in a headline: 50% sport, 50% video game, 100% politics 26. It is a newspaper headline. I record it as a headline, not as proof.
Where I stop asserting
I do not assert current Russian government control over Phygital International. I do not assert embezzlement, fraud or hidden funding. None of the documents consulted demonstrates it. I assert three things. The launch had a documented state and political dimension. The transition to an international private structure is declared, not demonstrated to the public. And every city or public body that funds a future edition must itemize the instrument, the counterparts, the collective interest and the payments. That applies to Kazan, to Astana and to any Brazilian city hall that one day receives the invitation.
The yardstick is the same for everyone. Esports is not an apolitical paradise: governments, funds and national brands finance championships. The difference I claim is one of transparency, not purity.
The math that does not add up
Part 5 of 10. This part assumes you have read The geopolitics behind Phygital. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
The scoreboard: two games, one sum
In the Phygital football final in Astana in August 2026, the decision came in two stages. According to the official Kazakh government account, one team won the digital stage 1–0 and lost the physical stage 3–2; the aggregate was 3–3, and the title was decided on penalties, 7–6, with US$ 150,000 for the champion 435. It was a good final. But look at the arithmetic: a goal in the video game is worth the same as a goal on the pitch. Why? What proportion of simulation skill and pitch football skill does this scoreboard measure? Under what conditions does one stage dominate the result? In a stable composite sport, the weighting between the parts is a normative decision: justified, reviewed and comparable across seasons. Here, one of the parts changes version whenever the game’s publisher decides.
The ranking that counts followers
The 2025–2026 club ranking regulation, developed jointly by the community and the company and approved on April 11, 2025, combines sporting results with a tournament-quality indicator, provides points linked to clubs’ and athletes’ social media presence, sets communication and media-production criteria for assessing competitions and, in the tiebreak of the overall standings, cites a club’s number of followers 11. I do not claim that followers replace victories: there are real sporting points and tournament tiers. I claim what the document says: popularity enters the machine that ranks who is best. In June 2026, the direct-entry programme for the Games of the Future published assessment criteria that included performance, social reach, quality of the media plan and commercial activation potential 12. Invitations based on brand value exist in many sports. Presenting them as sporting merit does not.
Opinion. When audience scores points, the athlete also competes as an influencer, and whoever has more followers, not more game, gains an access advantage. It may be good business. It is not sporting meritocracy.
Promise and number
The figures for Astana changed from one source to another, and the change is the datum:
| What was announced or held | Source |
|---|---|
| July 2025 plan: 13 disciplines (2026 coverage recalls 16), more than 1,500 athletes from nearly 100 countries, US$ 10 million prize fund | The Times of Central Asia, July 2025 and July 2026 2334 |
| Before the event: more than 800 participants from more than 50 countries, 8 disciplines, prize fund above US$ 4 million | Organizer’s press release, June 2026 28 |
| Total prize fund of US$ 4.75 million according to the government, and US$ 4.65 million according to the event FAQ | Government of Kazakhstan and official FAQ 435 |
| Event held: 8 disciplines, three of them Esports with no physical stage (Dota 2, PUBG and Mobile Legends) | Government of Kazakhstan and the event’s official site 435 |
Do the arithmetic with the coverage’s own numbers. From 13 disciplines in the announcement of the time (16, in the version 2026 coverage recalls) to 8, a cut of roughly 40% to 50%. From US$ 10 million to a little over US$ 4 million in prizes, less than half. From more than 1,500 athletes to more than 800, and from 100 countries to more than 50, about half 34. Projects adjust, and adjusting is no sin. What is required is an explanation, and The Times of Central Asia recorded the change without finding the reason for the cuts 34. I do not claim anyone lied: the sources have different dates and natures. I claim that whoever asks for public investment on the basis of launch numbers should demand the final ones, and that the public has the right to know why the promise became half.
What it costs to run two sports at once
| Item | Why it weighs |
|---|---|
| Physical arena | Court, track or gym at broadcast standard, in addition to the digital space |
| Licensed software | Third-party license, subject to updates, changes of terms and availability |
| Hybrid production | Camera and commentary crews for two environments, integrated into a single broadcast |
| Dual officiating | Field referee and digital specialist |
| Dual integrity | Doping control for the physical sport and anti-cheating for the digital one |
| International operations | Travel and logistics for clubs and athletes to stages and finals |
This table is cost logic, not an audit. No organizer has published, as far as I could find, a cost per athlete or per event that would allow comparison with a pure Esports tournament or an equivalent traditional sports competition. The burden of publishing falls on whoever asks for the investment. Without that data, "innovative" is an adjective.
Opportunity cost
Public money is finite. What a hybrid event receives, another programme does not: training for coaches and referees, athlete grants, digital inclusion, school access to infrastructure, community physical sport, permanent Esports circuits. I do not claim that any of these alternatives would yield more in every case. I claim that the responsible manager compares. A Kazakh MP compared the event’s estimated cost to that of six schools 23. One may dispute the sum. One cannot dispute the method.
The world compared
Part 6 of 10. This part assumes you have read The math that does not add up. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
Comparison is the antidote to the slogan. Below, what is documented in each case and what it teaches. The table does not give Phygital the worst grade of all. It gives it the grade of someone who has not yet handed in the work.
| Case | What is documented | What it teaches |
|---|---|---|
| Olympic Movement (2021–2025) | Olympic Virtual Series (2021) and Olympic Esports Week (2023), with federations and publishers; partnership with Saudi Arabia ended on 10/30/2025 and a new approach announced 1625 | Esports and traditional sport engage without a mandatory physical stage. Even the IOC reviews partnerships in which state money and governance intermingle |
| Russia (2023–2025) | Announced federal funding of roughly 5.3 bn rubles; presidential ceremony; supplier claims of roughly 587 m rubles in 2025 8914 | State projection has a cost and leaves unpaid bills. An announcement is not an audit |
| Kazakhstan (2025–2026) | Postponement from 2025 to 2026 after floods; parliamentary request for further postponement, with a 62 bn tenge estimate; statement of funding "exclusively from sponsorship"; state fund in the event title 2324 | Where parliament and press exist, cost becomes public debate. Where they are missing, it becomes an announcement |
| United Arab Emirates (Dec 2025) | Edition held in Abu Dhabi, December 18–23, 2025 28 | I found no verifiable cost or funding data in the sources consulted. Transparency is pending here too |
| Cycling (UCI, 2018–2026) | Virtual cycling incorporated into the UCI constitution in 2018; platform partnership in 2019; first World Championships in December 2020, with real physical effort on stationary bikes connected to the platform; platform replaced from 2024 32 | Physical and digital integrated inside the sport’s federation. The federation is in charge and the platform is replaceable |
| Modern pentathlon (UIPM, 2021–2023) | Riding replaced by obstacles: consultation (11/2021), testing of variants (05/2022), 83% vote (11/2022), IOC endorsement (10/2023) 33 | Combining events requires a process to change one of them. In Phygital, the game changes when the publisher updates it |
| Brazil (2024–2026) | Games Legal Framework (Law No. 14,852/2024), on manufacture, commercialization and commercial use of games and protection of children and adolescents, with regulation reported in October 2026 27; General Sports Law, whose art. 36 conditions federal transfers on democratic governance, social control and transparency set out in the bylaws 15 | Brazil has already written the conditions: proof before public money. The discussion precedes the showcase |
Three observations, all about method. On governance, Phygital International’s chief executive admitted that the movement has something to learn 24. On money, I found no public final report of cost and funding for any edition. On recognition, the Olympic Movement, when it approaches Esports, does so with federations and publishers, and with pauses for review. That is the standard any public policy proposal should be compared to. And in physical-digital integration, the example that exists came from inside sport, not from a parallel flag 32.
Brazil: the ladder reaches the House
Part 7 of 10. This part assumes you have read The world compared. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
This article has four chapters. The first three tell what Phygital has already done in Brazil between 2024 and 2026, what it promised and what it delivered, who speaks on behalf of what, and why the public seal is the currency the movement is missing. The fourth looks at an event held in a state legislature as a showcase of the same mechanism. It comes last on purpose: the event passes, the ladder stays. Anyone reading years from now will find the same logic, and the final chapter works as a case study.
Rule of reading. A fact comes with a source and a date. Inference and opinion are marked. Where I did not find something, I write "I did not locate it", which is different from "it does not exist". Names of people stay out: I write to roles, not against individuals.
Chapter 1 · What has already happened in Brazil
The chronology, with sources only
| Date | What happened | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Feb 2024 | The Brazilian operation presents itself in a broadcast partnership with another entity that also called itself a confederation | 20 |
| Jul 28, 2024 | The Brazilian executive, introduced as the event’s director of international operations, says Brazil will bid to host the 2027 world edition, puts the cost at more than US$ 10 million (the outlet writes R$ 50 million) and says it is "impossible to do without the support of the government as a whole". The outlet records that representatives of the Brasília Government traveled to Russia earlier that year | 37 |
| Late 2024 | The Brazilian commercial operation is launched and presents itself as the event’s official representative in the country. This is self-declared | 38 |
| Jan 2025 | "National" football and basketball championships in São Paulo, in a municipal facility: 16 teams per sport and about two hundred players, according to the publicity. The text names no body that recognizes the "national" label | 38 |
| Feb 25, 2025 | Phygital International announces Brazil among four shortlisted candidates to host the 2027 world edition and promises the decision for the summer of 2025 | 39 |
| Apr 3, 2025 | Seminar at the São Paulo City Council, organized by the Brazilian operation, with the support of a councilman | 21 |
| May 30, 2025 | The press treats Brazil as the favorite to host 2027 (the outlet’s word) and expects an announcement within the year. The executive speaks of a dossier of more than a hundred pages and of conversations with "people in Brasília". São Paulo and Brasília are the cities in play | 40 |
| Jul 2025 | A Brazilian club reaches the final of the football qualifier in Abu Dhabi (21 clubs, six places), loses 6–4 to a Mexican club and secures a place at the December event | 42 |
| Aug 2025 | A pop-culture channel announces broadcast exclusivity and official stages inside a festival in Campina Grande (PB), with a chance to compete for a "total prize of 10 million dollars" in Kazakhstan | 22 |
| Sep 12, 2025 | The association that calls itself the national confederation of phygital sport becomes active in the Federal Revenue registry | 18 |
| Oct 25–26, 2025 | Circuit stages at the Campina Grande festival, co-produced with the State Secretariat of Culture and the Paraíba government. The publicity calls them regional stages and, in one piece, national finals | 2246 |
| Dec 18–23, 2025 | Games of the Future in Abu Dhabi. A Brazilian dancer, whom the event’s official blog presents as representing Great Team Brazil and Phygital Brazil, is Phygital Dancing runner-up. The Great Team Brazil basketball team is eliminated in the quarterfinals, 39–22. A TV portal echoes the Brazilian broadcast under the headline "PHYGITAL World Cup" | 4445 |
| Apr 9, 2026 | More than a year after the list, the rights holder itself still cites Brazil among the shortlisted for 2027, and opens bids for 2028 to 2030 requiring endorsement from governmental or official authorities | 41 |
| Jul 29 – Aug 9, 2026 | Games of the Future in Astana: more than 800 participants from more than 50 nationalities and prizes above US$ 4 million. In dance, the same dancer reaches the quarterfinals. The Brazilian operation’s page reports no results and gives the dates as August 1 to 9 | 4347 |
| Nov 7, 2026 | The last event shown as concluded on the operation’s page: an online Shooter final, on the FACEIT platform | 47 |
Opinion. Read the middle column as a block. In two and a half years, the verifiable balance is this: events took place, athletes competed, a club reached a qualifier final, and a Brazilian dancer was runner-up in Abu Dhabi. The merit of those athletes is real and is not in question. I did not locate a Brazilian podium in a team discipline. This is spectacle sport on a modest scale, and it is perfectly legitimate. What is not legitimate is the distance between that balance and the vocabulary that accompanies it: national, official, world, recognized, favorite.
The promises and what arrived
I call semantic slippage the distance between what a sentence says and what a document proves. The table gives the sentence, what I located and my reading. The first two columns are fact, or what someone claimed, with a date. The third is opinion.
| What was said | What I located | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Official representative and official competition (2025) | Official, in those pieces, is the license from the event’s rights holder, which describes itself as a commercial-management promoter funded by the host city and partners 41. No act of a public authority or of a sports federation is cited 3847 | A trademark license is official among those who sign it. Beyond that, "official" binds no one, and the word takes the place of recognition that does not exist. |
| National championship, national finals (Jan and Oct 2025) | In January, 16 teams per sport, no recognizing body cited 38. In Campina Grande, the same stage is regional in three pieces and "national finals" in one 2246 | "National" is a publicity adjective. A national title requires a federative base, and this series has already shown what separates one from the other. |
| Brazil would be strong in 12 of the 24 disciplines (Jul 2024) | The executive’s self-assessment, with no numbers 37. Results I located: a club in a qualifier final 42, an individual runner-up in dance and a team eliminated in the basketball quarterfinals in Abu Dhabi 44, and the same dancer in the quarterfinals in Astana 43. I did not locate a podium in a team discipline | The athletes’ merit is not in question, and the runner-up place in dance is real. But "strong in half the disciplines" is a sentence that calls for a table, and the table was not published. |
| Brazil is the favorite to host 2027 (May 30, 2025) | The word is the outlet’s, not the rights holder’s 40. The decision was promised for April 2025, then for the summer of 2025 and for the May 2025 Summit 39. On April 9, 2026, Brazil was still shortlisted 41. I did not locate an announcement of the 2027 host | A favorite with no decision for over a year is a favorite of what? A host bid that never arrives also costs: expectation, political agenda and public managers’ time. |
| Competing for a US$ 10 million total prize (Aug 2025) | It was Astana’s official plan at that point. Article IV showed the retreat, from US$ 10 million and more than 1,500 athletes to more than US$ 4 million and more than 800 283443. By discipline: US$ 400,000 in basketball, with US$ 100,000 to the champion, and US$ 75,000 in dance, with US$ 20,000 to the champion 43 | The headline number is for the whole event. A Brazilian qualifier competes for a fraction of it, and only if they get there. Selling the total to the athlete and the sponsor and leaving the per-discipline bill for later is routine omission. |
| World Cup and one of the most relevant events on the gaming scene (Dec 2025) | Headline and text of a TV portal 45. The organizer describes itself as a commercial promoter and reports more than 800 participants in 2026 4143 | "World Cup" is the name of a tournament with an international federation, national federations and qualification through them. Here there is a promoter and a network of members who pay an entry fee. |
| International recognition and Gold Member seal (2025/26) | The community lists three membership categories (founding, full and associate), with no Gold, charges US$ 100 or US$ 500 to join and does not require a federation 519 | Paid membership in an open network is a commercial association. Recognition is another verb. |
| Brazil has a solid esports history; Phygital would broaden the sector’s professionalization (Dec 2025 and Jul 2026) | The TV publicity pieces make the claim with no indicator at all 45. Esports are treated as the credibility base of a circuit that is hybrid by definition | It borrows the credit that Esports built over two decades, and the promised benefit comes with no number. It is the mechanism that gives this series its name. |
Opinion. Each slippage, on its own, is ordinary marketing, and marketing exaggerates. The problem is the set. Official, national, world, recognized, favorite: five words that, one by one, look like decoration and, added together, build an institutional biography that the documents do not support. Someone who reads "World Cup" on TV, "national confederation" on the invitation and a government logo on a congress flyer reads five defensible sentences, each in isolation, that lean on one another. That leaning is what makes them useful for the next rung.
What this does not prove: that anyone acted in bad faith. Commercial exaggeration is common practice. What it proves: that the movement’s vocabulary in Brazil is systematically larger than its backing, and that the surplus always points in the same direction, that of looking like an institution.
Chapter 2 · Who speaks on behalf of what
The four roles
At four moments, the documents show the same person in four roles. In July 2024, the outlet introduces him as the event’s director of international operations 37. In January 2025, as CEO of the Brazilian commercial operation 38. In May 2025, as the Brazilian representative of the host bid 40. In November 2026, the congress page announces him as president of the entity that calls itself a confederation, also CEO of the commercial operation, and as moderator of three of the four sessions 17.
Opinion. Someone who appears in sequence as the rights holder’s representative, the commercial operation’s CEO, the face of the bid and the "confederation’s" president sits on all four sides of the table. None of this is illegal, and no doubt about good faith is needed for the request I make: that those roles be separated on paper. Who licenses whom, under what contract, at what cost, and who oversees whom. A confederation that oversees the commercial operation is a body. A confederation chaired by the commercial operation’s CEO tends to be an extension of it.
The public registry
The entity that calls itself a confederation appears in the Federal Revenue registry as a private association that began activity on September 12, 2025, with active status and a registered seat in Rio de Janeiro 18. The main registered economic activity is the production and promotion of sports events; the secondary ones include advertising-space brokerage, management of intangible assets, trade-fair and congress organization and the production of shows 18. The registry lists a single officer, the president 18. None of this is an irregularity. Many sports entities have similar registrations, and the Revenue does not assess representativeness. I record it for another reason: it is the registry portrait of an event promoter, and an event promoter has every right to exist and to promote events. What it does not have, merely by existing, is the right to be treated as a national confederation.
The operation’s website
On the November 10, 2026 check, the Brazilian operation’s home page describes it as an organizer of championships that join physical and digital sport, with a national ranking and its own platform 19. The entity that calls itself a confederation appears there only as a partner, in the identification of a logo. The "About us" page does not say who founded or runs the operation, does not describe the entity’s role and gives no creation date, bylaws, list of member bodies, minutes or tax ID 19. There is no transparency section, and the events page gives neither prizes nor participant numbers for any event 47. I do not claim those documents do not exist: they may exist at a notary. I claim that the public, the press and the House that receives the event cannot find them where they should be, and that transparency is the duty of whoever claims a national title.
The Gold seal
The same page has an "International recognition" section whose central sentence is that the Brazilian operation is a Gold Member of the World Phygital Community, a seal that, according to the site, grants Brazilian representation in the community and opens the way to competitions such as the Games of the Future 19; the same seal appears on the event page 17. The community’s own questions-and-answers page lists three membership categories (founding, full and associate) and does not mention Gold; it says associate entry costs US$ 100 and full costs US$ 500; and it answers that being a federation is not required 5. There may be a classification that page does not describe. The question is public: what is Gold, who grants it and by what criterion?
Opinion. Calling international recognition the membership in a network open to any legal entity, with no federation requirement and starting at US$ 100, is generosity of wording.
The change of confederation
In February 2024, the Brazilian operation presented itself in partnership with another entity that also called itself a confederation 20. In September 2025, the current one was registered 18. What justified the change? The question accuses no one: entities dissolve and re-form. But whoever asks for the national title on each new platform should explain what happened to the previous one.
Chapter 3 · Why the public seal is the currency
What the rights holder’s rules say
The rights holder describes itself as a commercial-management promoter and says each edition is funded by the host city and commercial partners, with governance and intellectual property solely its own 41. Bids for 2028 to 2030 require a letter of intent accompanied by endorsement from competent governmental or official authorities, and the public invitation is explicit: approach local sports authorities and press their representatives 41.
On the Brazilian bid for 2027, the executive told the press in 2024 that holding it would be impossible without broad government support, and the outlet recorded that representatives of the Brasília Government had traveled to Russia to open talks 37. In May 2025, he spoke of a dossier of more than a hundred pages, of contacts in Brasília and of two cities in play, São Paulo and Brasília 40. The texts name no bodies and describe no formal or financial support 40, and I did not locate any act of a Brazilian government committing resources to the event.
The logo’s path
My inference. The chain is short. A host bid requires public endorsement. Public endorsement materializes as a letter, an act or a logo. And logos, acts and letters are born at events such as seminars, congresses, the lending of a plenary hall and photos with officials. Every institutional ceremony is, for a dossier, a possible brick. I do not know what the Brazilian 2027 dossier contained. I know what the rights holder’s rules ask of future hosts, and I know that Brazil was still on the list in April 2026 41.
The series has already shown the pattern in other countries. In Kazan, the event was born with a presidential decree and a federal budget (Article III). In Astana, the event’s title appears tied to a state fund 24, and a lawmaker asked in 2025 for a postponement, estimating the cost at about US$ 115 million 23. Article IV showed the plan shrink. The question the Kazakh parliament asked at the end, Brazil needs to ask at the beginning.
What the law already requires
The General Sports Law already says what is required before any federal transfer: tax and labor regularity, financial viability and autonomy, and bylaws with democratic management, social control and transparency in the handling of funds (art. 36) 15. If public money appears in the future, those requirements apply with no shortcut, as does the legislation on partnerships with the public authorities 15. The use of a public facility by a private entity depends on an authorization act from the body that manages the space. Attending a ceremony, lending a plenary hall, announcing a partnership, using a court and making a transfer are different acts, with different controls. Whoever blurs them is confusing the taxpayer.
Who gains, who pays, who loses
From here on, everything is my inference, and it is marked.
Social. The social argument for Phygital is that it draws young people into physical practice. No organizer has published, that I have found, an indicator that this happens. A reverse effect is plausible: requiring a physical stage as a credential of legitimacy closes the door precisely to those Esports opened it to, to those with no court nearby, to those with mobility limits, to those who play from where they are. Esports is one of the most physically and geographically accessible sports there is. Making the court a requirement is regressing in inclusion under the banner of innovation.
Political. Brazilian public authorities need to know who they are talking to. Esports already has entities, leagues, publishers and state federations. A new entity that presents itself as a confederation and occupies the institutions session creates noise precisely where the public manager most needs clarity: who is the counterpart. The cost of that noise is paid by the whole sector, in time, in credibility and in stalled public policy.
Economic. A sponsor has finite budget and finite attention. Every real for an unproven hybrid is a real that does not go to a permanent circuit. If a Brazilian host ever gets confirmed, the bill, under the rights holder’s own rules, belongs to the city and the partners, and the most-cited public estimate runs to tens of millions of reais 37. Today’s symbolic support can become tomorrow’s argument to ask for a council seat, an incentivized project or a partnership with the State, and the House will have lent the stage for a bill it did not read.
Traditional sport. Traditional sport’s confederations go through governance requirements and the need for real memberships. When an identical title is used without that crossing, the title’s value falls for all of them. And the football hybrid depends on a licensed game and a court: what does it deliver to football? No published indicator.
The real benefit. It exists, and saying so is part of the discipline: matches played, audiovisual production, athletes who compete in both stages, prizes, a showcase for sponsors and possible use of idle facilities. This is an entertainment product, and it has market value. The 2025 publicity itself treats it that way: broadcast exclusivity with a pop-culture channel and stages inside a pop-culture festival, with optional disciplines such as medieval duels and robot battles 22. That festival was co-produced and sponsored by the state government 46. There is no indication, in the sources I read, that a cent of that sponsorship went to the phygital stage. I record it because the setting already had a state seal, and because that is how the ladder is built. The sporting and social benefit that is promised (inclusion, health, training, legacy) has, in no document I have found, a number.
Ten questions that hold with or without the event
- What is the legal relationship among the entity, the Brazilian commercial operation and the international company that holds the rights? Who licenses whom, and at what cost?
- Which member bodies make up the confederation? Where are the registered bylaws and the constitution minutes?
- What is the federative basis of an entity registered on September 12, 2025 that presents itself as a national confederation?
- What is Gold Member? Who grants the seal, by what criterion and at what cost, if the community’s rules page lists only founding, full and associate members?
- Did the Brazilian 2027 bid include the endorsement of any public authority? From whom, by what act and with what financial commitment?
- Is public money involved in any event of the circuit, directly, indirectly, through a tax incentive or through the use of a public facility? In what amount, by what authorization act and under what conditions, including price? If so, where are the qualification, the work plan and the accountability report?
- Who represents the athletes in the entity’s governance, and how were they chosen?
- Do the selection criteria for Brazilian places in international competitions include followers and reach, as in the international ranking regulation 11?
- What justified the change of confederation between 2024 and 2025?
- What outcome indicators will be published (participants, cost per athlete, retention, inclusion, legacy), and when?
Chapter 4 · The event as a showcase
Everything above holds without this chapter. It exists because the event is the most recent example of each mechanism described: the seal that leans on another seal, the vocabulary larger than its backing, the public logo with no declared role. I describe the program as the official page published it, with the source and consultation date in the evidence ruler. Nothing said or done at the event changes Chapters 1 to 3.
What is fact
The official page of the "Phygital Congress: The Future of Sports and Games in Debate at ALESP" published an Opening Table at the José Bonifácio Plenary Hall of the Legislative Assembly of the State of São Paulo 17. The same page named the Assembly only as the venue. It did not list it among realization, organization, partners, institutions or media, and recorded no support, sponsorship, request, proposing deputy or act of the Board 17.
The realization was by a "Sports & Business Forum". The organization was by three entities: a private association that calls itself the national confederation of the sport it itself promotes, the Brazilian commercial operation of the brand and a games and Esports association 17. The specialized press repeated this convening structure 48. Among the partners were leagues, companies and a sports-industry association. Under the heading "Institutions" appeared five logos, among them that of the São Paulo State Government and that of a sports incentive law, with not a word on each one’s role 17. The announced guests included a federal deputy, the Federal District’s Secretary of Sport and Leisure, the deputy secretary of Sports and Leisure of the city of São Paulo and an executive introduced as CEO of Phygital International 17. Announced presence is not endorsement, and I will treat it as such.
The program: four sessions and no "Phygital"
The four sessions were called "Opening Table"; "Beyond the Game: Strategy, Investment and Planning for eSports"; "eSports Institutions" (the spelling is the program’s); and "From Community to Market: Support for Esports and Its Opportunities" 17. None of the four titles contained the word that names the congress. Three dealt with Esports, its institutions and its support. Phygital was on the event’s label, and Esports was on the agenda.
Opinion. There, in its pure state, is the mechanism that gives this series its name. The theme, the audience, the invited authorities and the sought legitimacy belong to Esports. The name on the door is Phygital. One takes the house of one and hangs the sign of the other.
Who moderates whom
The president of the organizing entity, whom the page also presented as CEO of the Brazilian commercial operation (the four roles of Chapter 2), was the moderator of three of the four sessions and was also listed among the participants of the institutions session 17. The president of the games association that also organizes moderated the fourth session and took part in the institutions session 17. One of the sessions announced a debate on the sector’s "legal certainty" 17.
Opinion. Whoever organizes, moderates and debates the legitimacy of institutions, with the sector’s legal certainty on the agenda, has the duty to apply the ruler to themselves first. A debate on institutions in which the organizer sits on both sides of the table is not a debate, it is a presentation.
The confusion that gets monetized
The event declared, among its purposes, to promote Esports and phygital sport, in the same sentence, as tools of innovation, inclusion, entertainment and job creation 17. The program included a session on Esports institutions moderated by the head of a phygital entity 17. Read slowly. An entity whose reason for existing is a hybrid sport positioned itself as the institutional voice of Esports before sports authorities.
Opinion. It is exactly the mechanism that gives this series its name: taking the legitimacy Esports built over two decades and using it as backing for a product that depends on it and that, at the same time, suggests Esports is incomplete without a court. Esports did not ask for that addition.
To whoever goes on a stage like that
Appearing on stage is a choice, and every choice has a question. I do not write against people. I write to each role the program announced.
- To the invited authorities. Before confirming, did you ask for the bylaws, the list of member bodies and the instrument that formalizes the event? What did you authorize to be said about you in the publicity piece? That day’s photo will circulate for years, and the text beside it will not be yours. Recall Chapter 3: logo and photo are the raw material of a dossier.
- To the participants of the legal-certainty session. The sector’s legal certainty starts with that of the entities that debate it. Who checked the organizer’s? Or is the session about other people’s certainty?
- To the leaders of the leagues and associations present. On whose behalf do you speak? Do your members know your entity is listed as a partner of a congress that is called Phygital and debates Esports institutions?
- To partners and logos. Partnership in what, on what terms, with what in return? A logo with no described role is a free ride on the credibility of whoever lends it.
- To the organizers. No one asks you to show everything. I ask for what every entity that calls itself national should have at hand: bylaws, member bodies, minutes and the relationship with the international company. If it exists, publish it. If it does not, say so.
Three questions about an event like this
- What legal instrument formalized the Assembly’s support for the event: lending of space, act of the Board, request? Who signed it, and when?
- What do the logos in the "Institutions" section mean in the publicity piece: sponsorship, support or mere mention? The specialized press lists them as partners and supporters, without describing each one’s role 48. Is there a project approved under an incentive law? What is its number?
- Who invited a phygital entity to moderate the session on Esports institutions, and on whose behalf does it speak?
What I do not claim
I do not claim that the entity is irregular, that it was constituted fraudulently, that the Assembly has transferred or will transfer money, that any Brazilian government committed to hosting 2027, that the dossier of that bid contained any endorsement, or that the event amounts to legal recognition of anything. None of that is demonstrated. And saying it without proof would hand the adversary the only argument left. I claim that simple, public and legitimate questions exist, and that whoever organizes the event and whoever hosts it have the obligation to answer them before the photograph, not after.
Esports do not need a court
I close with the series’ premise. Esports did not arise waiting for someone to add a court. In a digital environment they built their own skills, training, refereeing, circuits and institutions. The Olympic movement has already shown that virtual competitions can engage with traditional federations without forcing anyone through a physical stage 16. And the UCI showed that, when there is real physical effort in a digital environment, integration happens inside the sport’s federation, not under a parallel banner 32. A practice’s legitimacy is measured by its own criteria, not by its resemblance to football. Whoever suggests otherwise does not broaden electronic sport: they repeat, in technological language, an old distrust of it.
And the ruler applies at home. Esports entities, mine included, must accept the same test of transparency, governance and results. The defense of Esports loses its credibility the minute it swaps one rhetorical monopoly for another.
Phygital can stay. The ladder cannot.
Phygital can stay as an event format, as a media product, as a well-designed educational experience. There is room for that. What it cannot do is keep climbing rungs without proving a single one. If public authorities, invited guests and the press ask the questions, the ladder stops. If they do not, it keeps climbing, and the cost of the confusion passes from whoever sells it to whoever pays for it.
The question that closes the series is the simplest: who gains from the confusion? So far, the answer is not sport, not Esports and not the taxpayer.
The Americas: the national seal as a product
Part 8 of 10. This part assumes you have read Brazil: the ladder reaches the House. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
This article looks at the Americas, where I work through PAMESCO, the continental body, and WESCO. It is the region where the movement’s "national member" label travels, gets displayed and, in my opinion, is often put to work for purposes that have little to do with sport. The article has four chapters: what the community’s own public documents show about the Americas, what they do not show, a signed opinion on a pattern I call by its name, and a checklist that anyone can apply to any national entity, mine included.
Rule of reading. A fact comes with a source and a date. Inference and opinion are marked. I name no national entity in this article, and that is deliberate: the documents are public and anyone can open them. What I assert about them, I assert about the lists, not about any line of them. The opinion in Chapter 3 is about a structure, not about a name.
Chapter 1 · What the public lists show
| Document | What it says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Dec 2025 | The community publishes a note on its school games in Latin America. It says members in three countries of the region (Guatemala, Colombia and Brazil) signed a cooperation agreement in 2025. It reports a school event in Guatemala on Sep 1, 2025, with 30 schools and academies; a qualifying phase in Colombia run with a district sports institute, with more than 15,000 students in Phygital Dancing sessions at public schools; and 12 schools in a first school circuit in Brazil. The note mentions no travel and no fees. It also repeats the community’s claim of presence in more than 115 countries | 51 |
| Leaderboard 2026 | The incentive programme’s leaderboard lists 119 entities worldwide, ranked by points, headed "progress as of 10.03.2026" (the document does not say whether that is day-month or month-day). It does not define what the points measure. Of the 119, 21 are in the Americas | 50 |
| Catalog | The member catalog shows, on its first page of seven, six entries from the Americas. The page does not say who may become a member; it invites the visitor to apply | 49 |
The Americas in the 2026 leaderboard
| Reading of the list | Count | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Entries from the Americas | 21 of 119 | By the country column of the document |
| Name carries a commercial form (Inc, S.A., S.A. de C.V., S.A.S., SRL, Ltda, E.I.R.L., Ltd., EPP) | 10 | Read from the name as listed. I checked no registry |
| Name carries "association", "federation" or equivalent | 10 | Same method |
| Name carries neither | 1 | Same method |
| Entries with 35 points or more | 5 | Three of the five carry a commercial form |
| Entries with 2 points or fewer | 11 | Seven of them have zero |
Three readings, and only three. First, there is real activity: a school circuit exists, with numbers, public partners and schools. I do not dispute it, and nobody should use this series to do so. Second, the list confirms what the community’s own Q&A already says, as Article II showed: members need not be federations, and companies, clubs and associations are equally welcome 5. A company may be a member, and charging for membership is legitimate. Third, the list cannot turn a member into a national authority. It ranks entities by points. It does not say whom any of them represents.
Chapter 2 · What the documents do not show
- That any national member is recognized by its country’s Olympic committee or sports ministry. I read the community’s lists, not the national registries: absence in these documents is not absence in the world.
- The statutes, officers, terms of office or assembly minutes of any member.
- What any member’s delegation actually does when it travels to a community event: whether it sits in sessions, takes part in decisions, files a report, or whether its athletes enter a ranking path with recorded results and a continuing calendar. The school note, the only document of this kind I consulted, mentions no international travel 51.
- What the points entitle a member to. The leaderboard does not say 50; the community’s release of June 2026 ties its incentive programme to direct-entry places 12.
- What "more than 115 countries" counts: entities, people, events or applications 51.
Chapter 3 · Opinion: the one man show, esports tourism and the borrowed seal
Opinion, signed. I use the expression "One Man Show" as I have used it since my article of July 31, 2025, Esports and the One Man Show Entities: it is my position and I keep it. I name no entity. What follows is the criterion, so that anyone can apply it with a document in hand.
The structure. A one man show is an entity in which a single person centralizes decisions and operations. In Esports, it is often a national "federation" that exists mainly on paper. The signs, as I set them out in 2025, are these: it appears only when an international event asks for a national representative, and then it organizes an improvised qualifier instead of keeping a continuous national ranking; it has no recognition from its country’s sports ministry or Olympic committee and simply declares itself a federation; any Olympic-related recognition it cites covers a private event, with no public obligation to citizenship, education or athletes’ careers; and it is opaque about its leaders, its finances and its selection criteria. The signs apply to the structure, whatever the name on the door.
What PAMESCO did. For about two years, PAMESCO asked its members for documents: statutes, a registered assembly, accounts, a ranking system and an administrative structure. Those found, on the documents, to be one man shows were disaffiliated. I state this as the president of PAMESCO and I do not name the entities.
The cheap seal. In my opinion, a private network with open membership 5 offers this structure an unusually cheap input. For a joining fee that Article II quoted, the entity receives a line that sounds institutional: "national member of a world community". The line costs little, requires no recognition by anyone, and is read very differently by those who know the sports system and those who do not.
Esports tourism. The second use is personal, not commercial. By tourism I mean this: officials and athletes who travel to an international event not to discuss sports administration, in Esports and digital sport, nor to compete, climb a ranking and build a career, but to travel, to be seen, to take the photograph and to enjoy the trip. There is no package in this argument and no seller. Travelling is legitimate and enjoying it is no sin. The problem is when the trip is all there is: it returns home as a "participation in a world event", it feeds the entity’s public image, and nothing in the administration or in the athletes’ careers changes. In my opinion, a seal that costs little and a stage that welcomes everyone make this outcome easy. I found no document that measures it, and I name no one: this is a description of a risk, in my opinion, not an event I can prove.
The audience. The seal works on whoever cannot check it. People who have never been inside the international sports system do not know that recognition is a chain of documents: statutes, affiliation, recognition by national and international bodies, decisions taken in assemblies with minutes. They see a logo, a flag, a certificate and a flight. The member network offers the logo; it does not offer the chain, and it does not claim to. The difficulty lies with whoever displays the logo as if it were the chain.
The modest opportunity. The opening is small, and that is the point: a small opening needs only small virtue to be taken. There is no decree, no budget, no host city. There is a form, a fee and an audience that does not ask. Inference: a network whose headline number is countries can grow by adding entities that cost little to add, and the public document does not let anyone tell a national body from a one-person entity. I do not say that this is how the number was built. I say that the document gives no way of excluding it.
Whoever allies with the movement in the region does so freely, and I do not dispute that right. I dispute the silence about what the alliance is and is not.
Chapter 4 · Ten questions for any national entity
| Question | A good answer looks like | Where to look |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Who are the officers, and since when? | Names, roles and start dates, with rotation or term limits in the statutes | Statutes; registry of the entity |
| 2. Who may vote, and how often does the assembly meet? | Open membership, published minutes, recorded votes | Statutes; assembly minutes |
| 3. Is it an association or a company, and who receives the surplus? | The legal form is stated; a surplus is reinvested if the entity claims to be non-profit | National registry of legal entities |
| 4. Are annual accounts published? | Income by source (fees, sponsors, public funds, tourism) and expenses | Annual report; filings where public |
| 5. Is it recognized by the national Olympic committee or the sports ministry? Which document says so? | A dated act or certificate, not an "alliance" or a "partnership" | The recognizing body’s own site or registry |
| 6. Is it affiliated to an international federation recognized by the Olympic Movement? | The federation’s own member list names it | The federation’s website; governance principles in 7 |
| 7. What does "member" status give it, in writing? | The charter and rules define rights and votes, and the entity claims no more 56 | The community’s charter and Q&A |
| 8. What did its delegation do at the last international event it attended? | Sessions attended, positions taken, votes cast and a report to its own members | Delegation report; the event’s published programme and minutes |
| 9. Did its athletes enter a ranking path after that event? | Results recorded in a published ranking, a following calendar and a route to the next stage 1112 | Ranking tables; national and continental calendars |
| 10. Who audits the nine answers above? | A body outside the entity: members, a fiscal council or a regulator | Statutes; fiscal council minutes |
Passing the checklist does not prove that an entity is good, and failing it does not prove that it is bad. It moves the burden: from the athlete, who has to trust, to the entity, which has to show. The checklist applies to my own organizations first.
Fact where it cites, opinion where it says so. I name no entity and accuse no one. Daniel Cossi
Africa: the number is not the continent
Part 9 of 10. This part assumes you have read The Americas: the national seal as a product. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
WESCO works on this continent, and I write this article as the head of an organization that does. It follows the method of the previous article: what the community’s own public documents show about Africa, what they do not show, a signed opinion on the same structure, and four extra questions that only a continental count makes necessary.
Rule of reading. A fact comes with a source and a date. Inference and opinion are marked. I name no national entity: the documents are public and anyone can open them. What I assert about them, I assert about the lists, not about any line of them. The opinion in Chapter 3 is about a structure, not about a name.
Chapter 1 · What the public lists show
| Document | What it says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Mar 2025 | The community’s release on a delegation visit to South Africa says it has members from 23 African countries and that, over the previous year, its African members hosted 16 phygital tournaments with 240 clubs | 52 |
| Leaderboard 2026 | The incentive programme’s leaderboard, described in the previous article, lists 119 entities worldwide. Of them, 34 are in Africa | 50 |
| Undated | Two national outlets report events run by member entities: a first phygital football tournament organized by a national esports federation as a qualifier for the 2025 world championship, and a tournament in another country in which 16 teams compete for ranking points towards qualification for the 2026 Games. The text retrieved shows no dates | 5354 |
| 2026 | Asked about Africa after the Astana Games, the chief executive of Phygital International pointed to the continent’s existing representation in the community and to South Africa’s level of participation, and said South Africa would be a good place to land the Games | 55 |
| 2026 | The rights holder’s pages describe the community as a network of more than 120 member organizations in over 115 countries, whose members run the local competitions that make up the first stage of qualification | 56 |
Africa in the 2026 leaderboard
| Reading of the list | Count | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Entries from Africa | 34 of 119 | By the country column of the document |
| Name carries "association", "federation", "committee", "league" or "organization" | 21 | Read from the name as listed. One of them also carries "Limited". I checked no registry |
| Name carries a commercial marker only (Ltd, Limited) | 2 | Same method |
| Name carries neither (a group, a brand or another form) | 11 | Same method. One entry is a person’s name |
| Entries with 35 points or more | 5 | Three of the five carry an association or federation word |
| Entries with 2 points or fewer | 24 | Twenty-one of them have zero |
Three readings, and only three. First, there is activity: tournaments were played, a continental first was announced, a federation organized a qualifier. I dispute none of it. Second, a count of members is a count of sign-ups. The community’s own Q&A accepts companies, clubs and associations alike and more than one member per country 5. The count grew from 23 countries in March 2025 to 34 entries on the 2026 leaderboard, and in that leaderboard 21 of the 34 show zero points. The document does not define the points, so I conclude nothing about activity: I only note that a member count and a record of activity are two different things. Third, the list does not say whom any entry represents in its own country.
Chapter 2 · What the documents do not show
- That any African member is recognized by its country’s Olympic committee or sports ministry. I read the community’s lists, not national registries: absence in these documents is not absence in the world.
- The statutes, officers, terms of office or assembly minutes of any member.
- What a member’s delegation does when it travels to a community event, and whether its athletes enter a ranking path afterwards.
- Who paid for the tournaments the members hosted: fees, sponsors, public money or the community itself.
- What "more than 115 countries" counts 56, and how the 23 countries of March 2025 relate to the 34 entries of 2026.
Chapter 3 · Opinion: the same structure, seen from Africa
Opinion, signed. The structure is the one I call "One Man Show", as in my article of July 31, 2025, Esports and the One Man Show Entities: a single person centralizing decisions and operations, a "federation" that appears when an international event asks for a national representative, improvised qualifiers instead of a continuous ranking, no recognition from the sports ministry or the Olympic committee, and opacity about leaders, finances and criteria. It is my position and I keep it. I name no entity, and I assert nothing about any line of the lists.
What Africa adds. One more thing makes the seal cheap: distance. On a continent of many countries and many languages, a member list is often the only map most people ever see, and a logo on a certificate is hard to check from a thousand kilometres away. Inference: that is exactly where a "national member" label travels furthest with the least verification. I do not say that it happened. I say that the lists give no way of ruling it out.
Esports tourism. I use the word as in the previous article. It is not a package and not a seller. It is the trip taken only for the trip: officials and athletes who go to an international event not to discuss sports administration in Esports and digital sport, nor to compete, rank and build a career, but to travel, to be seen, to take the photograph and to enjoy it. Travelling is legitimate. The problem is when the trip is all there is. Inference: for a small entity anywhere, and the more so where resources are scarcer, a flight to a world event is a very large prize, and a prize that large can become the goal. I found no document that measures this, and I name no one.
Whoever allies with the movement on the continent does so freely, and I do not dispute that right. I dispute the silence about what the alliance is and is not.
Chapter 4 · Four more questions for a continental count
Apply first the ten questions of the previous article. A continental count calls for four more:
| Question | A good answer looks like | Where to look |
|---|---|---|
| 11. Is it the only member from its country? If not, who decides which one speaks for the country? | One entity recognized by the national authority, or a written agreement among the members 5 | The community’s member list; the national sports authority |
| 12. Does its activity show in the community’s own results? | Tournaments hosted, teams ranked and points recorded in published tables | Leaderboards and tournament pages |
| 13. Who paid for the tournaments it hosted? | Fees, sponsors, public money and the host entity declared in published accounts | Accounts; contracts |
| 14. What did it bring home from the trip? | A report to its members, a ranking path for its athletes, a decision taken in a session | Delegation report |
Passing does not prove that an entity is good, and failing does not prove that it is bad. The questions move the burden from the athlete, who has to trust, to the entity, which has to show. They apply to my own organizations first.
Fact where it cites, opinion where it says so. I name no entity and accuse no one. Daniel Cossi
Sources
Part 10 of 10. This part assumes you have read Africa: the number is not the continent. If you landed here directly, go back to the start: Introduction.
- Amazon Ads, "What Is Phygital Marketing?". Current attribution of the term, in 2007, to an advertising executive; lexical authorship unresolved. advertising.amazon.com/library/guides/phygital
- Phygital International, pages "About PI" and "The PI LAB". phygitalinternational.com
- FrancsJeux, interview of 10/13/2021 with the originator of the earlier project. francsjeux.com
- Government of Kazakhstan, press release of 08/10/2026 (gov.kz); official Games of the Future 2026 page (gofuture.games).
- World Phygital Community, "Questions & Answers" (member categories, joining fees, federation requirements). worldphygital.org/questions-and-answers. Consulted 11/10/2026.
- World Phygital Community, charter revised on 05/30/2024 (worldphygital.org/documents/wpc-charter.pdf); Play the Game, 2022 study on weighted voting in international federations.
- International Olympic Committee, Basic Universal Principles of Good Governance (update of 09/09/2022).
- BUSINESS Online, report of 04/30/2023. business-gazeta.ru
- The Moscow Times, reports of 03/04/2024 on the Games of the Future in Kazan (expert assessments, budget above 6 billion rubles, opening with the Russian president).
- Phygital International, "About PI": declared roles of the company and the community.
- World Phygital Community, Regulations on the ranking system in Phygital Sports, approved 04/11/2025.
- World Phygital Community, release of 06/26/2026 on direct-entry places through an incentive programme.
- World Phygital Community, releases of 07/16/2026 and 09/14/2026 on leadership changes and the new chair’s plan.
- Kommersant, report of 02/07/2025 on supplier lawsuits relating to the Kazan event.
- Law No. 14,597/2023 (General Sports Law), art. 36, per Agência Senado (06/15/2023) and Mattos Filho (2023); Law No. 13,019/2014 (partnerships between public administration and civil society organizations). The requirements apply depending on the type of entity, source of funds and legal instrument, not to all private activity.
- International Olympic Committee, Olympic Esports FAQ (Olympic Virtual Series 2021; Olympic Esports Week 2023).
- Official page of the event, on the Brazilian operation’s website (phygitalgamesbr.com.br/eventos/phygital-na-alesp/). Consulted 11/10/2026.
- National Register of Legal Entities, Federal Revenue Service, via public API. Consulted 11/10/2026. Full data on file with the author.
- Website of the brand’s Brazilian operation. Consulted 11/10/2026.
- News from February 2024 on the broadcast partnership (acontecendoaqui.com.br; abcdacomunicacao.com.br, 02/28/2024).
- São Paulo City Council, note of 04/04/2025 on the seminar of 04/03/2025.
- Gazeta Esportiva, 2025, on exclusive broadcast rights, the stage at a pop-culture festival in Campina Grande (PB) and the announced total prize of US$ 10 million.
- The Times of Central Asia: report of 09/18/2025 on the parliamentary request for postponement; reports on the postponement from 2025 to 2026 and the sponsorship-funding statement.
- The Astana Times, August 2026, interview with Phygital International’s chief executive; event title linked to a state fund.
- Reuters and IOC statements, 10/30/2025, on the end of the partnership with the Saudi Olympic Committee for the Olympic Esports Games.
- Le Temps, report on the opening of the Games of the Future in Astana, July 2026.
- Law No. 14,852/2024 (Legal Framework for the Electronic Games Industry); Agência Câmara, 05/06/2024; O Povo, 10/15/2026, on the regulation.
- PR Newswire: releases on Abu Dhabi 2025 and Astana 2026; 24.kz, preparation report on the prize fund.
- Decree of the President of the Russian Federation No. 927, of 12/19/2022, on holding the Games of the Future in 2024 in Kazan (items 5 and 6, on funding); text at rulaws.ru; news in evening-kazan.ru, 12/20/2022.
- Russian Ministry of Sport: inclusion of phygital sport in the national register of sports on 01/31/2023 (RBC; Snob; Sport24); creation of the Russian Phygital Sport Federation on 02/22/2023 (News.ru); sport rules approved by order of 12/28/2023.
- Realnoe Vremya and Kazan city hall website: host announced on 06/16/2022 at the St Petersburg International Economic Forum; first Phygital Games in Kazan, 09/21–23/2022 (dspkazan.com).
- International Cycling Union (uci.org): releases of 2020, 2021 and 2023; Cyclingnews (2019 and 08/18/2023); SBS (2019).
- International Modern Pentathlon Union (uipmworld.org): timeline of the obstacle discipline integration (11/04/2021 to 10/16/2023); NBC Sports and Sports Travel Magazine on the vote, the appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport and athletes’ reaction.
- The Times of Central Asia, "From Controllers to Courts: Kazakhstan Prepares for Games of the Future", 07/17/2026.
- gofuture.games: news of the Phygital Football final, 08/09/2026, and the event’s FAQ page.
- Le Temps, "À Kazan, la Russie fait jeux à part", February 2024.
- Dust2, 07/28/2024, "Brasil se candidatará a sede do Phygital Games em 2027" (dust2.com.br). Statements by the Brazilian executive and the outlet’s records on cost and the Brasília Government.
- AdNews, 01/23/2025, "Phygital Games traz campeonatos de futebol e basquete a São Paulo" (adnews.com.br); Sympla, event page "Phygital Basquete" (January 2025).
- Phygital International, release of 02/25/2025 (PR Newswire): Brazil, Serbia, South Africa and Uzbekistan shortlisted for 2027; gofuture.games, 11/29/2024 (decision expected April 2025); World Phygital Community, 03/18/2025 (announcement expected at the May 2025 Summit).
- Itatiaia, 05/30/2025, "Brasil mira sediar Games of the Future em 2027; entenda o que é o evento" (itatiaia.com.br). Statements by the Brazilian executive; "favorite" is the outlet’s assertion.
- gofuture.games, 04/09/2026, "The hunt is on for GOTF host cities 2028, 2029 and 2030" (letter of intent with endorsement from governmental or official authorities; the deadline appears as August 1, 2026 on the site and July 1 in the press release; Brazil, Serbia and Uzbekistan cited as shortlisted for 2027); phygitalinternational.com, "About PI" (commercial-management promoter; editions funded by the host city and commercial partners). Checked on 11/10/2026.
- gofuture.games, page "Phygital Contenders: Abu Dhabi" and release of 07/30/2025 (PR Newswire/WAM): Football, 07/25 to 07/29/2025, 21 clubs, six places; final won 6–4 by the Mexican club over the Brazilian one.
- Phygital International and PR Newswire, releases of 03/12/2026 and August 2026 (official dates, participants, prize fund); World Phygital Community, "GOTF 2026 ends after 12 days" (August 2026); gofuture.games, FAQ (prize by discipline: basketball US$ 400,000, dance US$ 75,000); sheepesports.com and La Nación (champions: US$ 100,000 in basketball, US$ 20,000 in dance).
- abudhabi2025.gofuture.games, "Semi-finals line-up for Phygital Basketball confirmed" (12/21/2025: basketball quarterfinals, 39–22); gofuture.games, community blog profile of a Brazilian Phygital Dancing athlete (05/21/2026) and news of the Astana Phygital Dancing final (08/07/2026), which identify the Brazilian dancer, 2025 runner-up and representative of Great Team Brazil and Phygital Brazil.
- O Universo da TV, "Copa do Mundo PHYGITAL estreia cobertura inédita no Brasil pela PlayTV" (December 2025); Jornal do Brás and Sala da Notícia, broadcast release for the Games of the Future 2026 (July 2026).
- Ei Nerd (einerd.com), pieces from August to October 2025 on Imagineland On The Road in Campina Grande (PB): realization and co-realization by the State Secretariat of Culture and the Paraíba Government; regional stages and national finals of the circuit.
- Brazilian operation’s website, "Eventos" page (phygitalgamesbr.com.br/eventos/). Checked on 11/10/2026.
- ND Games, 11/10/2026, "ABGE no Congresso Phygital da ALESP: o que é Phygital" (ndgames.com.br).
- World Phygital Community, "Members catalog" (page 1 of 7: six entries from the Americas; no statement on who may become a member). worldphygital.org/members-catalog. Consulted 11/12/2026.
- World Phygital Community, "Current status of the incentive program for 2026" (leaderboard headed "progress as of 10.03.2026"; 119 entities; points not defined). worldphygital.org/documents/current-status-of-the-incentive-program-for-2026.pdf. Consulted 11/12/2026. Counts and legal-form reading by the author, from names as listed; no registry checked.
- World Phygital Community, "Phygital School Games Reach Thousands of Students Across Latin America", dated 08/12/2025 on the site (read here as December 8, 2025, because it describes January 2026 finals as upcoming). worldphygital.org/blog/post/phygital-school-games-reach-thousands-of-students-across-latin-america/. Consulted 11/12/2026. The figure of more than 115 countries is the community’s own claim.
- World Phygital Community, release of 03/28/2025 (PR Newswire), "South Africa Leads the Charge in Africa’s Phygital Sports Revolution": members from 23 African countries; 16 tournaments and 240 clubs in the previous year. Copy consulted at finanzen.net on 11/12/2026.
- Ghana Esports Federation’s first phygital football tournament as a qualifier for the 2025 world championship (myjoyonline.com). Consulted 11/12/2026; the text retrieved shows no date.
- Citizen Digital (Kenya), "Kenya set to host Phygital Rivals tournament": 16 teams competing for ranking points towards 2026 Games of the Future qualification. Consulted 11/12/2026; the text retrieved shows no date.
- BRICS Africa Channel, "Africa on the Radar as Games of the Future Eyes Next Phase of Global Growth" (2026): answers by the chief executive of Phygital International on African representation in the community and on South Africa as a host. Consulted 11/12/2026.
- gofuture.games, pages "What is phygital sport and how does it work?" and "How to qualify for the Games of the Future" (more than 120 member organizations in over 115 countries; members run the local competitions of the qualification pathway). Consulted 11/12/2026.
